4
Dispatch → Meta → Reference
SC Recommendation Archive: Vote AGAINST 'Commend Twobagger' | OWL
·
..
·
..
·
Background Information
Proposal title: 'Commend Twobagger'
Author: Jakker city
Purpose: To award Twobagger a badge of commendation for their service in 10000 Islands, contributions to the general defending community, and writings about switching R/D allegiances.
Author: Jakker city
Purpose: To award Twobagger a badge of commendation for their service in 10000 Islands, contributions to the general defending community, and writings about switching R/D allegiances.
Links
The Office's Analysis
Twobagger was a defender with the South Pacific's ally 10000 Islands before defecting at the beginning of this year to join the infamous raiding organization The Black Hawks. The proposal appears to be commending him for his contributions to defending, which the South Pacific would normally support. However, closer inspection reveals that the proposal's author is Jakker, a longtime commander in the Black Hawks. It is clear that Jakker chose to commend Twobagger specifically in order to anger 10000 Islands. South Pacificans should not tolerate such action against an ally of ours. The fact that out of all the notable defenders and former defenders in the world, Jakker chose to propose a commendation of the one who defected and switched sides to become a raider suggests that his motivation is merely to bring another World Assembly badge into the Black Hawks. But the proposal never even explicitly mentions that Twobagger is now a raider, leading uninformed voters to think that they are commending a military hero when in fact they are rewarding a military enemy. Furthermore, Twobagger's own actions as listed in the commendation proposal are not terribly special and do not meet the typical standard of the Security Council. The duplicitousness in this proposal is outstanding and it should be called out for what it is: an attempt at trolling our ally, the defender community, and the World Assembly. The Office strongly urges a vote against.
Commend Twobagger is a product of the worst habits of the Security Council and the Gameplay community in general. Lets be clear: Twobagger betrayed 10000 Islands and joined their enemies in The Black Hawks. Regardless of the motive or anybodys opinion on that, they are not an active defender and 10000 Islands does not approve of being used in such a manipulative way to commend them. The commendation purposefully misleads the rest of the game into thinking that Twobagger is a current wonderous defender, when in all actuality they are a turncoat raider.
Commend Twobagger is a product of the worst habits of the Security Council and the Gameplay community in general. Lets be clear: Twobagger betrayed 10000 Islands and joined their enemies in The Black Hawks. Regardless of the motive or anybodys opinion on that, they are not an active defender and 10000 Islands does not approve of being used in such a manipulative way to commend them. The commendation purposefully misleads the rest of the game into thinking that Twobagger is a current wonderous defender, when in all actuality they are a turncoat raider.
For
From TSP Citizens
Fihami is the Minister of Military Affairs of the South Pacific. (Note: FiHami had originally voted for this proposal, but later edited their vote to against because they "realize[d] this proposal is in bad faith". This statement was made before they edited their vote and may not reflect their current views.)
From the World
Pallaith is a minister and former Delegate of the North Pacific. He posted the following on the North Pacific's offsite forum:
Penguin Dictators is the Jarl of Foreign Affairs of Wintreath. They posted the following on the on-site discussion thread for this proposal:
Against
From TSP Citizens
Fihami is the Minister of Military Affairs of the South Pacific. (Note: FiHami had originally voted for this proposal, but later edited their vote.)
Qvait is a current member of the Council on Regional Security and a former Minister of Foreign Affairs of the South Pacific.
Daytime to night is a former minister and current citizen of the South Pacific. They posted the following on the on-site discussion thread for this proposal:
Sandaoguo is a member of the Council on Regional Security and a former Minister of Foreign Affairs of the South Pacific. They posted the following on the on-site discussion thread for this proposal:
From the World
Praeceps is a citizen of the North Pacific. He posted the following on the North Pacific's offsite forum:
The Python is a card farmer and defender. They posted the following on the on-site discussion thread for this proposal:
·
WELCOME BEGINNER'S GUIDE WRITING GUIDE VOTING CENTER DISCORD
WELCOME BEGINNER'S GUIDE WRITING GUIDE VOTING CENTER DISCORD